This wouldn’t work for every use case related to RSS subscription, but I think it would work for many people. Most importantly, it would work for me and that’s how good design solutions begin.
This is the workflow for how I subscribe to a site’s feed now (click on the images to see them embiggen)…
When I click on the Subscribe button, I am taken to Bloglines (my reader of choice) to finish the subscription process.
I shouldn’t have to subscribe twice. The initial Subscirbe button was enough. I don’t think I have ever changed the default settings and really it’s something I can easily do within Bloglines later. Ah well. I take care of this page’s needs by clicking the Subscribe button on this page.
How It Should Go
I select my reader of choice, click Subscribe, and get a confirmation message. I can click the Close to make the subscroiption section go away and I am back to reading the site.
Why is this good?
I am already on the site, so there’s no reason to take me to my feed reader to read what I was already reading. I can always go to the reader later. Besides, the reader (Bloglines anyway) only loads up the 10 most recent posts and on most sites, I can read those on the front page of the blog.
My way only takes focus away from the page to complete the task, then I am back to reading. In the future I can easily consume content from this site via the reader.